
FEATURES
The Court of Appeal in Abuja on Thursday affirmed the election of Senator Monday Okpebholo as the duly elected Governor of Edo State, upholding his victory in the September 21, 2024, governorship election conducted by the Independent National Electoral Commission.
Delivering the lead judgment, Justice Mohammed Danjuma dismissed the appeal filed by the Peoples Democratic Party and its candidate, Asue Ighodalo, describing it as lacking in merit.
The three-member panel ruled unanimously, reiterating the decision of the Edo State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal.
Justice Danjuma held that the appellants failed to prove any miscarriage of justice or provide credible witnesses and documentation to support their allegations of over-voting.
“The foundation of the appellants’ case having collapsed, the appeal lacked merit and is hereby dismissed,” the court ruled.
In reaction, Ighodalo vowed to challenge the verdict at the Supreme Court.
Speaking with The PUNCH, the Publicity Secretary of the Edo State PDP Caretaker Committee, Chris Nehikhare, confirmed the decision:
“We are surely taking the matter to the Supreme Court after today’s judgment, and we shall do so within the stipulated time.”
Meanwhile, Governor Okpebholo called on Ighodalo and the PDP to accept the Court of Appeal’s decision and join him in moving Edo State forward.
In a statement issued by his Chief Press Secretary, the governor said the judgment, which reaffirmed the will of the people, should signal an end to divisive politics.
“Governor Monday Okpebholo commends the judiciary for its diligence and commitment to justice. This ruling is not just a victory for our party, the All Progressives Congress, but a triumph for democracy and the rule of law in Edo State.”
“The governor urges the opposition and Asue Ighodalo to reflect on the judgment. Prolonged litigation only distracts from the urgent task of governance and the delivery of democratic dividends.”
Reiterating his earlier stance, Okpebholo extended an olive branch to all political actors, regardless of party affiliation, emphasising that the state’s development must take precedence over political rivalry.
“Now is the time to embrace the spirit of sportsmanship and statesmanship. The legal process has run its course, and the judgment of the Court of Appeal is clear,”he said.
Governor Okpebholo reaffirmed his administration’s commitment to a “people-first” agenda, prioritising development across infrastructure, education, healthcare, and economic empowerment.
“We urge all well-meaning citizens to remain calm and continue with their lawful activities. This affirmation of our mandate re-energizes the government to continue working tirelessly in the best interest of all residents of Edo State,” he stated.
INEC had declared Okpebholo winner of the election, having polled 291,667 votes to defeat PDP’s Ighodalo, who garnered 247,655 votes.
Dissatisfied, the PDP and its candidate filed a petition before the Governorship Election Petition Tribunal in Abuja, challenging the outcome.
On April 2, the three-member tribunal, led by Justice Wilfred Kpochi, dismissed the petition, ruling that the petitioners failed to substantiate claims of over-voting and electoral irregularities.
The tribunal affirmed that Okpebholo received the highest number of valid votes and found that the petitioners failed to link their allegations to credible evidence.
The petition, marked EPT/ED/GOV/02/2024, alleged widespread irregularities, including non-serialisation of ballot papers, inaccurate collation, and faulty computation of results in 765 polling units.
The petitioners also accused INEC of failing to comply with the Electoral Act and claimed sensitive election materials were neither serialized nor pre-recorded, allegedly facilitating rigging in APC’s favour.
During the trial, the petitioners presented 19 witnesses, including a subpoenaed Senior Technical Officer from INEC’s ICT department who tendered 154 BVAS machines from 133 polling units to support claims of over-voting.
INEC, the first respondent, did not present any witnesses, while Okpebholo, the second respondent, called one, and the APC presented four.
However, the tribunal faulted the petitioners for failing to call polling unit agents or presiding officers who could directly attest to the alleged malpractices, describing most of the testimonies as hearsay.
“It remains the law that documents do not speak for themselves. Petitioners must demonstrate their allegations with credible, relevant witnesses,” the tribunal ruled.
The tribunal further held that the BVAS machines submitted were not properly examined or linked to the allegations and were effectively “dumped” on the court without analysis.
“None of the witnesses could speak to the BVAS machines or demonstrate their contents. The machines remained dormant,” Justice Kpochi said.
On the issue of ballot serialisation, the tribunal confirmed that the materials used by INEC complied with the necessary guidelines and held that the petitioners failed to prove any violation of the Electoral Act.
Unsatisfied with the ruling, the PDP and Ighodalo proceeded to the Court of Appeal, which has now upheld the tribunal’s verdict in its entirety.
With the appellate court’s dismissal, the legal battle now shifts to the Supreme Court, where Ighodalo and the PDP hope to have the decision overturned.
A war of words broke out on Thursday between the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory, Nyesom Wike, and Senator Ireti Kingibe over the recent sealing of properties in Abuja for failure to pay ground rent.
Senator Kingibe, who represents the FCT in the Senate, criticised the clampdown as unconstitutional and high-handed.
In a statement issued on May 26, 2025, and shared via her official X handle, she warned that the mass closure of buildings—including offices of key institutions like the Peoples Democratic Party Secretariat and Access Bank—violated the rights of residents and business owners.
But Wike’s camp swiftly fired back through a statement his Senior Special Assistant on Public Communications and Social Media to the FCT Minister, Lere Olayinka.
The minister accused Senator Kingibe of displaying “ridiculous ignorance” of the Land Use Act and turning every issue into a personal vendetta against Wike.
“It is embarrassingly ignorant for a serving senator to be unaware of the provisions of Section 28 of the Land Use Act,” Olayinka said. “Ground rent is not optional. It’s a legal obligation tied to land ownership, and failure to pay it over 10, 20, even 43 years cannot be brushed aside.”
He insisted that Kingibe’s opposition was politically motivated and called on her to “purge herself of hatred for Wike,” rather than shielding defaulters under the guise of defending legality.
Senator Kingibe, however, maintained her position, arguing that while enforcement of ground rent is necessary, the method of sealing off properties without due process is illegal.
She cited the Land Use Act and the Urban and Regional Planning Act, which, according to her, prescribe fines or surcharges—not arbitrary property takeovers—as penalties for default.
“No Nigerian’s property can be lawfully seized or sealed solely due to ground rent default,” she said, calling the FCT Administration’s actions “indiscriminate” and “insensitive” to current economic realities.
The senator also warned that such abrupt enforcements erode public trust and worsen the economic hardship facing residents of the FCT. She pledged to push for legislative action to ensure compliance with due process in future enforcement activities.
Olayinka countered that Kingibe’s interpretation of the law was selective, stressing that non-payment of ground rent constitutes a breach of the Certificate of Occupancy—grounds enough, under the law, for revocation.
“Would Kingibe, as FCT Minister, fold her arms while landowners refuse to pay what is legally due for over four decades?” he asked.
The spat comes despite President Bola Tinubu’s recent intervention granting defaulters a 14-day grace period to settle their arrears. While that move temporarily halted further sealing of properties, the clash between Kingibe and Wike’s camp underscores a deepening political divide over the handling of public policy in the capital.
Kingibe urged residents to remain calm and law-abiding, assuring them that the matter was receiving her full attention.
“We are committed to ensuring that dialogue, justice, and due process prevail,” she stated.
The suspended Governor of Rivers State, Siminalayi Fubara, has commended President Bola Tinubu for his timely intervention which halted the degeneration of the political crisis in the state.
Fubara said the president deserved all the kudos for acting wisely to salvage and stabilise the state.
According to Fubara, the story in the state “would have been different” if President Tinubu failed to act when he did.
Fubara stated thus at a meeting with leaders and stakeholders of the Simplified Movement as part of activities to mark his two years in office as Governor of Rivers State in Port Harcourt on Thursday.
It would be recalled that Tinubu had, in a nationwide broadcast on March 18, 2025 declared a state of emergency citing the need to restore law and order as the crisis between Fubara and his predecessor, Nyesom Wike festered.
He subsequently announced the suspension of Fubara, his deputy, Mrs Ngozi Odu, and all elected members of the House of Assembly of Rivers State for an initial six months.
This was followed by the nomination of retired Vice Admiral Ibokette Ibas as the Rivers State administrator to steer the affairs of the state, during the period of the emergency rule.
Fubara, in a statement on Thursday by his media aide, Nelson Chukwudi, said his supporters, Rivers people and Nigerians needed to thank President Tinubu for his swift intervention to salvage the state from looming anarchy arising from the festering political crisis.
He also said a peace and reconciliation process had been activated, assuring that all executive and legislative institutions would be restored.
He tasked his supporters to be open to the ongoing peace process to enable the state to move forward.
He said, “We are already in the peace process. I want you to thank Mr President for his timely intervention to salvage the situation, and stabilise the polity and the State. If not for Mr President, the story today would have been different.
“I don’t know how he gets his information, but the truth is that he acted with wisdom at the right time. He is the one you should thank. And let me also thank him personally for his intervention, and the personalities across the country, who moved in and appealed to him to intervene.
“We have to come down from our high horses and subject ourselves to the peace process. And that is what we are doing. What is important is for the State to move forward. It is not about you, the interest of the State is paramount.”
The suspended governor assured that democracy and good governance will soon return in the state, with both arms working together for the good of the people.
Fubara stated, “I want to assure you that the issues will soon be resolved, and you will come back to your offices; not just at the Executive arm, but also Legislative arm.
“I also believe that the strong relationships we had before will return, and we will begin to work together again, for the good and progress of the State. What is important is for us to have a forgiving spirit.”
The governor pleaded for forgiveness from anyone who may have felt disappointed in his handling of the crisis, emphasising that his actions were guided by a desire to protect the peace and progress of the state.
The governor explained that those expressing anger and grievances have the right to do so, but quickly added that the time has come for all to embrace peace, and pursue reconciliation and forgiveness for the development and progress of the state.
He expressed appreciation to Mr President for the steps he has taken as a father to restore peace, stability and good governance in the State, and assured reconciliation with the former governor and Minister of the Federal Capital Territory, Nyesom Wike, very soon.
The governor disclosed that since the President’s intervention, several reconciliatory meetings had been held, including some at the FCT minister’s residence.
He said: “There is no reason why there will not be peace between me and my Oga”, about the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory and his predecessor, Chief Nyesom Wike, adding, “There will be peace. We are meeting. We will reconcile.”
While asserting that he was indebted to the people for their sacrifices and opportunity to serve, the governor promised to continue to show respect for the people of the State, who entrusted him with the mandate.
“One important thing in this life is respect. I want to earn the respect of the people, not force it on them…I’m with you completely,” he said.
He thanked Rivers people and all Nigerians who stood by him during the period of political turbulence, acknowledging their loyalty and prayers.
He noted that but for the political situation, orchestrated by the crisis, the second year celebrations would have been used to showcase some of the key milestones recorded by the administration in various sectors across the state.
He assured that the government would bounce back stronger, more united and engineered to deliver quality dividends of democracy to the people.
The member representing the Arochukwu/Ohafia Federal Constituency in the House of Representatives, Hon. Ibe Okwara Osonwa, has congratulated Governor Alex Otti on the occasion of his second anniversary in office, describing his tenure so far as visionary, transformative, and deeply impactful on the lives of Abians.
In a statement personally signed by Osonwa on Wednesday, the lawmaker commended the governor’s leadership style, which he said has ushered in a new era of purposeful governance in Abia State.
Osonwa particularly commended Governor Otti for signing into law the Greater Ohafia Development Authority (GODA) bill, a legislative milestone designed to accelerate development in the Abia North Senatorial District of the state.
He described the establishment of GODA as a bold and strategic move to bring infrastructure, investment, and administrative attention to long-neglected communities.
According to him, the signing of GODA into law represents a clear commitment to inclusive growth and development.
He further lauded Governor Otti’s unprecedented strides in infrastructural development across the state, especially in his federal constituency. These include the ongoing reconstruction of the 41.4-kilometre Ohafia-Arochukwu Road, which had been abandoned for decades despite its critical economic importance.
He also noted the commencement and progress on the Omenuko Bridge, the Ndi Okereke Abam-Arochukwu Road, and the Umuahia-Uzuakoli-Abiriba-Ohafia Road, all of which are strategically important to improving access, mobility, and commerce across Abia North.
The federal lawmaker applauded the governor’s Smart Schools initiative across the state as a major leap in educational transformation. Osonwa said the project symbolises a new era in education for children in Abia State.
He noted that with the plan to establish smart schools in all 17 local government areas of the state, Governor Otti is laying the groundwork for a digital, innovative, and future-ready education system.
Rep. Osonwa also recognised the administration’s efforts in revamping the healthcare sector, especially the ongoing retrofitting of 200 primary healthcare centres and the upgrade of select general hospitals to specialist status.
He said such interventions are vital in ensuring accessible and quality healthcare services across the state, especially for rural and underserved communities.
He concluded by assuring Governor Otti of his continued support and partnership in delivering people-centred projects to the good people of Arochukwu/Ohafia Federal Constituency and beyond.
Rep. Osonwa noted that the governor’s achievements within two years are not just impressive but a testament to what visionary leadership anchored on accountability, transparency, and service can accomplish.
“As we mark this second anniversary of Governor Alex Otti’s administration, we celebrate a leader who is not only fulfilling his campaign promises but is also setting a new standard for governance in Abia State.
“His dedication, courage, and commitment to rebuilding our state are visible and commendable. The people of Arochukwu/Ohafia are proud to be part of this new Abia,” Osonwa stated.
Also, the National Orientation Agency (NOA), Abia State, has joined to extol and celebrate the achievements of the governor within two years in office.
According to the agency, in a goodwill message on Wednesday, Governor Otti has proven that public funds can be used judiciously in the transformation of the state.
NOA advocates for leaders with a genuine intention to make positive changes that would improve the lives of the people.
The NOA stated that making a positive impact does not require a long stay in governance, noting that it requires visionary leadership, integrity, stewardship and accountability.
From the sporting sector, the Chairman of Enyimba Football Club of Aba, Amb Kanu Papilo’ Nwankwo, has congratulated Otti on the 2nd anniversary of his administration.
Amb Kanu, who made his felicitations and that of the club known through Enyimba Media, said, In two years of selfless and uncommon stewardship of our dear amiable and dynamic Governor, Abia indeed is moving forward.
In the release, he appreciated Gov. Otti’s visionary policies and all-around sector signature projects that have continued to positively impact Ndi-Abia like never before.
He also thanked the governor for his unwavering support towards sports growth/youth development in the state, which he said inspires all, “including us at Enyimba to succeed”.
Parts of the message read: “Enyimba FC Chairman, Amb Kanu Nwankwo, congratulates our amiable & dynamic Governor, His Excellency, Dr Alex Chioma Otti OFR, the Executive Governor of Abia State, on his administration’s 2nd Year Anniversary.
“We at Enyimba are very proud of your administration’s excellent and all-around sector signature projects/human development policies that have impacted ‘Ndi-Abia’ positively, including sports growth/youth development, and we say thank you, sir!
Also hailing Otti, the Chairman, Abia State Council of Traditional Rulers, Eze Linus Nto Mbah (LINTO), congratulated Otti, his family and members of the State Executive Council on the 2-year anniversary of the governor.
Eze Nto Mbah, in his anniversary goodwill message, noted with profound joy the numerous giant strides achieved by Governor Otti within 2 years in office and said it was unprecedented.
Eze Linus Nto Mbah, who described Governor Otti as CHIOMA NDI ABIA, pointed out that within 2 years in office, Governor Otti has changed the narratives in road infrastructure, which cuts across various communities in the state; renovation of schools; introduction of free and compulsory basic education; retrofitting of 200 primary healthcare centres; upgrading of some healthcare facilities to specialist hospitals; and security and said the achievements are unparalleled.
He also noted that Governor Otti has prioritised the welfare of the workers and pensioners in the state, paid arrears of salaries and pensions owed to to civil servants and pensioners by the previous administration and initiated regular payment of workers’ salaries and pensions on the 28th of every month, as well as created a conducive environment for workers.
The royal father commended the governor for increasing the monthly stipend of the traditional rulers in Abia State from a paltry sum to at least 250,000 Naira each, completing and furnishing the secretariat of the traditional rulers at the JAAC Building, organising the first Abia State Traditional Rulers Workshop and ensuring special Christmas packages are made available for them.
The yet-to-be declared second term ambition of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has continued to gather momentum as the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC), governors and National Assembly members elected on the party’s platform, unanimously adopted him as their sole presidential candidate ahead of the 2027 general elections.
They all spoke Thursday at the first APC National Summit which held at the State House Abuja.
…Tinubu’s remarks
And to President Tinubu, who graciously accepted their decision, there is nothing wrong with a one-party state in a constitutional democracy.
The president thanked the stakeholders for his endorsement and also welcomed the defectors into the APC which he described as the party of choice.
“Sweep the dust away. Thank you for your endorsements,” he said. “Welcome to the progressives, sweep them clean,” he said, adding: “There’s nothing wrong with a one-party system.”
The president also reaffirmed his partnership with Vice President Kashim Shettima, referring to him as part of his team.
On the economy, he said “our economic reforms are working. There’s nothing good that comes easy.”
“Senate President, Speaker, where are the tax bills? I hope they are on their way,” he said.
The president also called on Nigerians to remain resilient, promising to listen to their concerns.
“We have the opportunity to make this continent a great one, not just Nigeria,” he said, while cautioning that indiscipline, corruption and abuse of power remain significant barriers.
He pledged that Nigeria’s economic revival is underway and that the country would be industrialised within the next few years.
“We have the mission, we have the vision,” he declared, adding that while he cannot offer political positions to everyone, he urged patience and unity within the party.
..Ganduje sets tone of event
Setting the tone at the event, APC National Chairman Dr. Abdullahi Umar Ganduje told the gathering that it’s only the party that has power to nominate the candidate.
“As the only body which (sic) has the power to field any candidate, I hereby affirm the various endorsements and declare President Bola Ahmed Tinubu as the sole presidential candidate of APC in 2027,” he said.
While canvassing for support for the implementation of the Renewed Hope Agenda of Tinubu-led administration, Ganduje said the party cannot go into the 2027 poll divided, unprepared, or reactive.
“Our goal must not only be to win elections, but to lead with purpose, to earn the trust of Nigerians continuously, and to inspire belief in governance again,” he said.
Ganduje, who eulogised the developmental strides recorded under the Tinubu-led administration, noted that he, alongside the National Working Committee (NWC) have gradually transformed the APC from an electoral force into a governing institution.
The Donald Trump administration has given Harvard University 30 days to respond to a formal notice that could strip the institution of its ability to host international students.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security late Wednesday issued a “Notice of Intent to Withdraw” Harvard from the Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP), citing alleged failures to comply with federal reporting requirements and maintain an environment “free from violence and antisemitism”.
The five-page notice invites the university to submit sworn statements or evidence within 30 days to refute the claims.
The move comes just as U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs prepares to hear arguments in Harvard’s lawsuit against the administration’s earlier attempt to revoke its student visa certification, an effort the university says was imposed without following legal protocols.
The timing of the notice could impact Thursday morning’s court hearing in Boston. Federal lawyers informed the judge of the new development late Wednesday.
The dispute is taking place at the same time as Harvard’s graduation ceremonies. While graduates walked through Harvard Yard in celebration, lawyers for both sides were preparing for what could become a major legal fight.
At the heart of the case is Harvard’s ability to admit international students, who make up more than 25% of the university’s total enrollment.
The Trump administration has frozen $2.2bn in federal funding to Harvard and demanded compliance with eliminating DEI programmes, banning masks at campus protests, and adopting merit-based hiring and admissions.
Harvard has challenged those demands in court, calling them politically motivated and unconstitutional.
Trump on Wednesday suggested that Harvard should reduce its international student population to “maybe around 15%, not 31%.”
He accused the university of showing “great disrespect” to the country and warned it was “getting in deeper and deeper”.
Harvard President Alan Garber has pushed back firmly, calling the federal actions “disproportionate and misdirected”.
He acknowledged ongoing concerns about antisemitism and inclusivity but argued the administration’s response punishes the institution broadly rather than targeting the specific issues it claims to address.
At Wednesday’s Class Day, former NBA star Kareem Abdul-Jabbar praised Garber’s stance, comparing it to Rosa Parks’ Civil Rights resistance.
Outside the campus gates, supporters reportedly gathered in solidarity. Retired immigration judge Patricia Sheppard, dressed in her judicial robe, held a sign reading “For the Rule of Law”.
Stakeholders in Nigeria’s business community have raised the alarm over the crippling impact of high energy costs on Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), warning that the current trend is unsustainable and threatening the survival of businesses across the country.
They issued the warning on Thursday in Abuja at an Energy Efficiency Awareness Campaign organised by the Abuja Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) in partnership with WINOCK Group, a conglomerate with interests in solar energy, lending, and agriculture.
Speaking at the event, the President of ACCI, Dr. Al-Mujtaba Abubakar, who was represented by the First Deputy President, Dr. Aliyu Idi Hong, described electricity as one of the biggest obstacles to doing business in Nigeria.
“Today, about 60 per cent of the operating cost of businesses goes to energy. That is not just alarming — it is devastating,” Hong said.
“You can imagine what’s left to pay salaries, reinvest in growth, or even stay afloat. That’s why we’re seeing businesses shut down every day.”
He noted that the situation calls for urgent government intervention, stating that energy challenges are stifling innovation and dragging down productivity in a country heavily reliant on MSMEs to drive economic growth.
“At ACCI, our mission is to promote sustainable commerce and economic prosperity. We’re actively advocating for sound energy policies that will fast-track the transition to a green economy,” he added.
Director General of ACCI, Mr. Agbaidu Jideani, stressed that poor energy efficiency remains a silent killer of Nigerian businesses.
“This campaign is aimed at catalysing a shift — from wasteful energy use to smarter, more sustainable practices.
The future of our economy depends on how efficiently we use energy, especially in the SME sector,” Jideani said.
Also speaking, the Founder and Group CEO of WINOCK Group, Mr. Sanmi Lajuwomi, said the high cost of electricity was the driving force behind the company’s foray into solar power solutions.
“WINOCK Solar has delivered over 5 megawatts of installed capacity for SMEs in Abuja alone. We’re now scaling up to other states to ensure small businesses can access clean, reliable and affordable power,” Lajuwomi revealed.
He said the firm’s mission is to ease the energy burden on MSMEs and help them redirect capital from diesel and generator maintenance into business expansion and job creation.
Participants at the event unanimously called on the federal government to adopt a more aggressive policy shift towards renewable energy and provide access to green financing and incentives for small businesses transitioning from fossil fuel dependency.
The Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria, Mr Olayemi Cardoso, has been named the Central Bank Governor of the Year at the 2025 African Banker Awards Gala.
The event was held in Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire.
The award, presented by African Banker magazine, recognises Cardoso’s “bold and strategic” leadership in steering monetary and regulatory reforms that have restored stability and confidence in Nigeria’s financial system, according to event organisers.
In a statement, the Awards Committee praised the Central Bank of Nigeria under Cardoso for implementing key policy measures aimed at stabilising the naira, improving transparency in the foreign exchange market, and re-establishing policy credibility.
The Committee noted that these efforts have laid the groundwork for long-term macroeconomic resilience and renewed investor confidence.
Dr Nkiru Balonwu, Adviser to the Governor on Stakeholder Engagement and Strategic Communication, accepted the award on his behalf.
She was accompanied on stage by the Bank’s Director of the Monetary Policy Department, Dr Victor Oboh, and the Director of the Banking Supervision Department, Dr Olubukola Akinwumi.
They were later joined by a member of the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), Dr Aloysius Uche Ordu.
“The award reflects the Committee’s recognition of Governor Cardoso’s recent achievements and the Central Bank’s critical role in addressing market imbalances and repositioning the Nigerian economy for sustainable growth,” organisers said.
Now in its 19th year, the African Banker Awards are organised by African Banker magazine with the African Development Bank Group as its official patron.
The annual event draws senior figures from government, banking, and development finance institutions across the continent to celebrate excellence in African finance.
Since his appointment in 2023, Cardoso has implemented several reforms to stabilise the forex market and attract foreign investment.
Some key reforms include the unification of exchange rates, which enabled the CBN to scrap multiple exchange rates and allowed a more market-driven system, reducing arbitrage opportunities and improving transparency.
The CBN worked on settling outstanding forex obligations of over $7bn to boost investor confidence and also implemented the reintroduction of a willing-buyer, willing-seller system and interventions in the forex market aimed at stabilising volatility.
He also limited government FX control by reducing artificial controls that distorted exchange rates, allowing the naira to find a more realistic value, as well as implementing policies to attract foreign direct investment (FDI) and portfolio investments, such as higher interest rates and improved ease of repatriation of profits.
The CBN under Cardoso also imposed stricter regulations on forex speculators and Bureau de Change operators to curb market manipulation, raised BDC recapitalisation to about N2bn and also introduced the Nigerian Foreign Exchange (FX) Code in January 2025, aimed at promoting ethical conduct and transparency within the nation’s foreign exchange market.
This FX Code initiative seeks to ensure that authorised dealers uphold the highest standards of professionalism and integrity when conducting FX transactions.
These reforms have been able to restore stability, boost investor confidence, and improve dollar liquidity in Nigeria.
The Minister of Information and National Orientation, Mohammed Idris, has said President Tinubu is not controlled by any cabal or shadowy inner circle.
Instead, he said, the president welcomes a wide range of perspectives, and then makes bold and informed decisions that are solely in the best interest of Nigeria.
A statement by media aide to the minister Rabiu Ibrahim disclosed that Idris stated this in Abuja on Thursday, while delivering his address at the APC National Summit with the theme “Renewed Hope Agenda: The Journey So Far.”
“You need to study the president very well. You can have your voice; you can say what you want to say; he will listen to you but his decision is ultimately his own. I think it’s important for us to recognize that,” he said.
Speaking on the theme of the summit, Idris said, President Tinubu remains committed to transforming Nigeria through the Renewed Hope Agenda, describing it as a bold, people-first blueprint that is turning obstacles into opportunities.
“The Renewed Hope Agenda,” the Minister said, “is about positively impacting the lives of the people of Nigeria, through bold decisions designed to unleash the full scale of Nigerian potential, in a way that has never been seen or done before.”
He recalled that President Tinubu inherited a nation at a crossroads and immediately moved with clarity and courage. “Among the first decisions the President made,” Idris explained, “were the removal of petrol and foreign exchange subsidies, which have been amongst the biggest impediments to Nigeria’s progress, costing us billions of dollars in losses and waste annually.”
The Minister noted that “true leadership involves the ability to make decisions that might be tough in the short term, but are guaranteed to deliver lasting returns.’”
Idris said the outcomes of the president’s reforms are now evident across all sectors through large-scale infrastructure, social investment programmes, revamping of the nation’s mining and petroleum sectors among others.
“At the federal level, the increased revenues have set a new standard for ambition and execution of large-scale infrastructure projects,” Idris said. He highlighted four signature highways — the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway, Sokoto-Badagry Superhighway, Calabar-Abuja Superhighway, and Akwanga-Jos-Bauchi-Gombe Highway — totaling more than 2,600km and linking communities and economies across the country.
He said, “ another flagship project driving regional integration is the Kano-Kaduna Standard Gauge Railway. This vital corridor is a key component of the Lagos-Kano railway modernization plan and is being delivered as a priority under the Renewed Hope Agenda. In the housing sector, the administration launched the Renewed Hope Cities and Estates Projects, an ambitious intervention aimed at addressing the nation’s housing deficit while stimulating job creation and urban renewal.”
The Minister said to support the growing digital economy, the Federal Government is deploying 90,000km of fiber optic cable nationwide, describing it as “unprecedented scale of broadband infrastructure (that) will not only bridge Nigeria’s digital divide but also support smart governance, attract digital investments, and enable secure e-services in education, healthcare, commerce, etc.”
Idris said about 300,000 Nigerian students are now benefitting from the National Education Loan Fund (NELFUND), while workers are accessing the new Consumer Credit Scheme to buy essential goods.
On security, Idris said, “our military has neutralized and arrested thousands of hostiles and rescued nearly 10,000 hostages. More than 25 new aircraft have been acquired, and the Navy has taken delivery of four new vessels.”
He hailed the president for establishing the Ministry of Livestock Development and Regional Development Commissions across the six geo-political zones in order to modernize and deepen agriculture and also ensure inclusive, zonal development.”
The Minister emphasized that the Renewed Hope Agenda is holistic and people-centered.
“At the other end of every programme and policy of the Tinubu Administration is an ordinary Nigerian whose life is being positively impacted. Nigerian enjoying equitable access to personal or business financing; a Nigerian seeing declining food prices; a Nigerian enjoying cheaper means of transportation, through CNG; a Nigerian grateful for access to on-grid or off-grid electricity through one of the administration’s several power initiatives; a Nigerian whose son or daughter can attend university because of NELFUND,” he said.
Idris highlighted the recent enactment of the Renewed Hope Nigeria First policy that mandates all federal ministries, departments and agencies to give absolute priority to Nigerian goods, services, and know-how when spending public funds.
“This,” he said, “is historically unprecedented, with the ultimate objective being to accelerate industrialization through local production and to insulate the Nigerian economy from global disruptions. Mr President, thank you for this most nationalistic policy, and for laying the foundation of Nigeria’s Economic Renaissance,”
The Executive Chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS), Zacch Adedeji, has raised alarm over Nigeria’s poor tax compliance rate, disclosing that only 19% of Nigerians currently pay taxes.
Adedeji made this revelation during the public presentation of a new book titled “Taxation: Essential Knowledge for Nigerian Children,” a publication supported by the FIRS to promote early tax education among the country’s youth.
Represented at the event by his Special Adviser on Research and Statistics, Aisha Mahmoud, Adedeji stressed that the findings were the outcome of several studies conducted by the agency.
“First of all, I want to say that we have run a couple of studies and we have found out that tax compliance is positively correlated with tax education,” he stated.
“When children are educated, they grow up to become responsible people, pay their taxes and do what is right.”
While noting the current tax compliance rate at 19%, Adedeji also pointed out that some other studies suggest the figure could be as low as 10% to 15%, indicating a potentially more dire situation.
According to him, the FIRS sees early education as a strategic tool to reverse this trend.
“It is easier to make younger children become tax compliant when they grow up than reform tax-dodging adults,” he explained. “That is why we support initiatives like this book launch.”
The book, co-authored by Aderonke Atoyebi and Ejura Haruna, is aimed at instilling foundational knowledge about taxes and civic duties in children from a young age.
Adedeji’s remarks come as the federal government intensifies efforts to broaden the tax net and improve revenue generation in the face of dwindling oil income and rising national debt.
In his second anniversary speech, President Bola Tinubu reaffirmed the government’s commitment to tax reforms, revealing plans to establish a Tax Ombudsman—a neutral body to protect vulnerable taxpayers and ensure fairness within the system.
“Most importantly, we are laying the foundation for a more sustainable future by introducing a new national fiscal policy,” President Tinubu said.
“This strategic framework will guide our approach to fair taxation, responsible borrowing, and disciplined spending.”
More...
Constitutional lawyer and Senior Advocate of Nigeria, Mike Ozekhome, has said that the rising cost of living and widespread public discontent under President Bola Tinubu’s administration could fuel a formidable opposition movement capable of unseating him in the 2027 general election.
Speaking in response to reports of an emerging political alliance between former Vice President Atiku Abubakar and 2023 Labour Party presidential candidate, Peter Obi, Ozekhome argued that if properly coordinated, Nigeria’s fractured opposition could defeat Tinubu, whose grip on state institutions remains a major hurdle.
“With the misery and disenchantment on the ground, a powerful force can ease him (Tinubu) out of power,” he said. “But the forces are massive, with Tinubu controlling virtually every apparatus of state power.”
He urged opposition blocs to consolidate, likening Nigeria’s political system to that of the United States where power typically alternates between two dominant parties. “We should have such a template where there is no dominant power bloc,” Ozekhome added.
Sharing Ozekhome’s view, another lawyer and rights activist, Abdul Mahmud, described Tinubu’s economic policies as neo-imperialist and harmful to the welfare of ordinary Nigerians.
“Nigerians have suffered enough under Tinubu and will continue to suffer as he proceeds with his neo-imperialist economic policies,” Mahmud told The PUNCH. “Nigerians are tired of Tinubu and anybody/anyone but Tinubu will do in 2027.”
However, some stakeholders have cautioned against overly optimistic projections, especially regarding the proposed Atiku-Obi alliance.
The National President of the Arewa Youth Consultative Forum, Yerima Shettima, said the arrangement — in which Atiku is reportedly offering Obi the vice presidential slot in a one-term presidency — requires closer scrutiny.
He said the alliance could be “a pragmatic approach to coalition-building within Nigeria’s complex political landscape, aiming to unify diverse voter bases and enhance electoral viability.”
“By aligning with Obi, who has garnered significant support particularly among the youth and progressive factions, Atiku may seek to rejuvenate his own political capital while positioning himself as a unifier in a fragmented political arena,” Yerima said.
He, however, warned that the proposal may stir intra-party tensions and invite questions about motive and sincerity.
“Is it a genuine attempt at fostering collaboration, or a calculated manoeuvre to consolidate power?” he asked.
Yerima maintained that it will ultimately be up to Nigerians to decide what political configuration best serves the country’s interest come 2027.
“Voters will make a meaning out of every permutation and decide what is good for them and the future of the country,” he noted.
The Manufacturers Association of Nigeria has called on the Federal Government to turn the Nigeria First Policy into law to boost the manufacturing sector.
MAN Director-General Segun Ajayi-Kadir, in his keynote address on Thursday at the 2025 BusinessDay Manufacturing Conference held in Lagos, said that gazetting the procurement policy would ensure it is implemented across all arms of government and the private sector.
‘Nigeria First’ is a procurement policy mandating Federal Government ministries, departments and agencies to prioritise locally made products in their budgetary allocations.
Ajayi-Kadir stated that manufacturing, which is burdened by high interest rates, can benefit from the policy when it is enforceable as law.
He recommended: “Make the Nigeria First Policy a binding law, and punitive measures should be put in place for violators. This is critical to give the policy legal standing, ensuring transparency, public awareness, and enforceability across government institutions and the private sector.”
Ajayi-Kadir warned that the Nigeria First policy risks going the way of past executive orders 003 and 005 that failed to make a tangible impact due to the absence of a formal legal framework.
He added, “Nigeria must seize this moment to transform its manufacturing sector by prioritising the patronage of local products. If we fail to nurture our own, we will forever be at the mercy of others.”
Meanwhile, MAN’s DG bemoaned the challenges manufacturers faced. He stressed that 767 manufacturing companies shut down operations in 2023 alone, while over 18,000 jobs were lost in 2024.
He added that rising costs, policy inconsistencies, infrastructural decay, and currency depreciation have made the manufacturing sector nearly unviable.
Meanwhile, MAN urged the government to resolve the $2.4 bn in unsettled foreign exchange forwards, reverse the 15 per cent increase in port charges by the Nigerian Ports Authority and remove the suspended but previously enforced four per cent Free on Board levy on exports.
Ajayi-Kadir also called for the fast-tracking of the Ajaokuta-Kaduna-Kano gas pipeline, which he said would inject 3.6 GW into the power grid and drastically reduce manufacturers’ energy burdens.
Further, MAN urged the Federal Government to adopt its 2024 Manufacturers Summit Report as working documents for a national industrial policy, stressing, “A nation without a clear industrial policy is like a ship without a rudder.”
The Dozens of students sitting for the ongoing West African Senior School Certificate Examination at the Government Secondary School, Namnai, in Gassol Local Government Area of Taraba State narrowly escaped death on Wednesday evening after their classrooms collapsed during a heavy downpour accompanied by a windstorm.
The students, along with teachers, corps members, and external supervisors, were reportedly trapped in the debris of the collapsed structures and had to be rescued by local residents who responded swiftly to their pain of anguish and cries for help.
Arewa PUNCH learnt that several students, both male and female, sustained varying degrees of injuries, with some reportedly suffering fractures to their limbs.
The victims are currently receiving treatment at a nearby Primary Healthcare Centre in the town.
A resident, Alhaji DanAzumi Lauris, who spoke with Arewa PUNCH in a telephone interview, said the incident happened around 6 pm, shortly after the second set of students had begun their exams.
“It was the second batch of students who had just moved inside the classrooms to sit for their exams that got trapped. The first set had already finished and left.
“The rains came suddenly with strong winds, and the old classroom structures couldn’t withstand it and collapsed on them,” he further narrated.
He added that the windstorm did not only bring down the school buildings but also destroyed several homes within the community.
In a related development, our correspondent also reports that students in Jalingo, the state capital, were also affected by Wednesday’s heavy rainfall.
Some candidates were forced to remain at their exam centres until after 1am, as the torrential rains made it impossible for them to return home earlier.
Arewa PUNCH investigations, however revealed that the students’ plight was further compounded by the late arrival of WAEC papers for the day, resulting in the delay in sitting for the exams which did not begin until 8:pm after many of centres received their question papers.
Efforts to get the Commissioner for Basic Education, Dr. Augustina Godwin to speak on the matter was unsuccessful as her phone line was not reachable as at the time of filing this story.
Organised Labour on Thursday delivered an unflattering assessment of President Bola Tinubu’s two years in office, saying his reforms and policies brought nothing but pain and suffering to Nigerians.
The labour movement countered Tinubu’s claims that the worst days are over, pointing out that his economic reforms have plunged over 150 million Nigerians into multidimensional poverty.
In a statement, the Nigeria Labour Congress President, Joe Ajaero, submitted that far from renewing hope, his government has merely recycled the same failed neoliberal experiments of the past.
However, the All Progressives Congress pushed back against Tinubu’s critics, accusing the NLC of misrepresenting the reality.
Responding to the criticisms against the President, the APC National Vice Chairman (South-East), Dr. Ijeoma Arodiogbu, said the NLC’s evaluation lacked depth and objectivity.
“Their statement was sponsored. The NLC failed to engage with the real issues and instead chose to grandstand,” Arodiogbu said.
“It’s disappointing to see a professional body making comments that sound more like what you’d hear in a marketplace. They ought to consult economists and policy experts before making such superficial remarks,” he added.
Speaking on Tinubu’s midterm record, Arodiogbu commended the President’s performance.
In a national broadcast to commemorate his second anniversary on Thursday, Tinubu touted the benefits of his reforms, saying, “We are on course to building a greater, more economically stable nation.”
He stated that his administration is on course to making life better for Nigerians.
Tinubu acknowledged the pains his reforms have unleashed, adding that he does not take the patience of citizens for granted.
“Today, I proudly affirm that our economic reforms are working. We are on course to building a greater, more economically stable nation. Under our Renewed Hope Agenda, our administration pledged to tackle economic instability, improve security nationwide, reduce corruption, reform governance, and lift our people out of poverty.’’
But Ajaero dismissed Tinubu’s assertions, stating that the government’s failure to move the nation forward had only proved once again that ‘’you cannot cure a patient by prescribing the poison that made him sick in the first place.’’
He said, ‘’When President Bola Tinubu took office on May 29, 2023, he promised a new dawn—bold economic reforms that would rescue Nigeria from fiscal instability and set it on a path to prosperity.
“But two years later, the only thing bolder than his rhetoric is the magnitude of suffering and hardship his policies have inflicted on workers and ordinary Nigerians.
“Far from renewing hope, his administration has recycled the same failed neoliberal experiments of the past, proving once again that you cannot cure a patient by prescribing the poison that made them sick in the first place.’’
The labour leader recalled how the sudden removal of the petrol subsidy sent shockwaves through an already fragile economy, causing fuel prices to skyrocket from N187 to over N600 per litre overnight.
Tinubu did not mention in his speech how much the country has saved from fuel subsidy removal, but he did indicate that net external reserves grew from $4 billion in 2023 to over $23 billion by the end of 2024.
While the government argued the move would free up public funds for development and reduce economic distortions, the NLC noted that Nigerians have seen no visible gains, only skyrocketing costs, business closures, and growing hunger.
“Instead of reinvestment, Nigerians got inflation so vicious that families now skip meals, businesses shutter daily, and transport costs consume the little that remains of workers’ wages,” the congress said.
The second pillar of Tinubu’s reforms, the unification of Nigeria’s multiple exchange rates, sought to enhance transparency and attract foreign investment. But the NLC said the policy has had a devastating impact on local production and consumer prices.
Ajaero stated that it only accelerated the naira’s collapse and imported inflation into the domestic economy, making everyday goods unaffordable.
“The naira, left to the so-called ‘market forces,’ has collapsed in value, turning Nigeria into a bargain basement for neighbouring countries while local industries suffocate under the weight of imported inflation,” Ajaero said.
What makes this pain even more frustrating, Ajaero observed, is that none of it is new, recalling the bitter pill and pains of past policies rammed down the nation’s throat by the International Monetary Fund.
He queried, ‘’We have seen this script before—subsidy removals, devaluations, and IMF-approved austerity—each time sold as the bitter pill Nigeria must swallow for a brighter future. But when has it ever worked?
“The same policies under past administrations only widened inequality, enriched a few, and left the majority poorer. Tinubu’s version is no different, except the suffering is deeper, the anger louder, and the government’s response more brutal.’’
He referenced the hyperinflation in the country, which he said had obliterated the workers’ wages.
Despite the optimism conveyed in the presidential broadcast, the NLC insists that macroeconomic statistics are cold comfort for citizens struggling to survive daily.
The union noted that economic performance is measured by how people feel, not by PowerPoint slides and selective data. “If this government truly wants to renew hope, it must abandon these cruel experiments and put Nigerians, not foreign creditors, at the centre of its policies.”
The Assistant General Secretary of the NLC, Chris Onyeka, told The PUNCH that the economic reforms seem like a deliberate imposition of pain on the poor in the service of foreign financial institutions and local elites.
“None of these policies are new. We have seen them under previous administrations. Each time sold as the bitter pill for a better tomorrow. But when has it ever worked?”
Tinubu introduced several policies to alleviate the impact of the fuel subsidy removal, such as the Presidential Compressed Natural Gas program to reduce dependence on petrol, lower transportation costs, and provide cleaner energy alternatives, helping to mitigate the impact of higher fuel prices.
The government implemented palliative measures such as direct cash transfers and food distribution programs aimed at cushioning vulnerable Nigerians from the immediate inflationary pressures caused by the sharp rise in fuel prices.
The union acknowledged the CNG intervention but described it as grossly inadequate given the scale of infrastructural deficits and transportation chaos.
“The only thing we single out is the provision of CNG buses for the use of Nigerian workers across the nation by the federal government to ease transportation, which remains inadequate and hampered by serious gas infrastructural deficits,” it said.
Beyond economic grievances, the NLC also decried what it called the Federal Government’s increasing hostility toward organised labour.
It cited unpaid wage awards, intimidation of labour leaders, the criminalisation of protests, and a consistent disregard for court rulings as examples of the administration’s authoritarian tendencies.
“For Nigerian workers, it has been two years of brutality, suppression, and broken promises,” Ajaero lamented.
The NLC also highlighted growing insecurity across the country as a critical concern, questioning the logic of discussing economic reforms when citizens face widespread kidnappings, insurgency, and banditry.
The Chairman of the Lagos State Council, Trade Union Congress of Nigeria, Gbenga Ekundayo, also faulted the fuel subsidy removal and called for a shift toward a production-driven economy.
“Transportation remains central to our economic structure, and removing fuel subsidies was a direct hit,” Ekundayo told The PUNCH.
The chairman said that, as an import-dependent country, higher fuel costs immediately affect the prices of goods and services, which affects the average Nigerian.
He argued that years of neglect of domestic production capacity have left the country vulnerable to global supply shocks and inflation, exacerbated by policy decisions that increase costs without compensatory measures.
“We’ve focused too much on subsidising consumption,” he said. “What we need is to subsidise production and support manufacturing, agriculture, and local industries so that we can bring down the cost of goods and build resilience into the economy.”
Ekundayo also criticised the inconsistency between the government’s rhetoric on austerity and its spending patterns, describing the disparity as damaging to public morale.
“Government is telling citizens to tighten their belts, but the political class is not doing the same,” he said. “There’s a glaring disconnect, and people are beginning to question whether the burden of reform is being fairly shared.”
However, he commended ongoing infrastructure projects, particularly road construction, saying they have the potential to stimulate job creation and improve the movement of goods and services.
“The construction works across different regions are a step in the right direction,” he said. “They can open up economic corridors and enhance trade. But the government must be transparent about the costs involved so that people can understand and own these projects.”
Ekundayo further stressed the need to strengthen Nigeria’s research and development capacity by forging stronger links between academic institutions and the real sector.
The NLC Chairman in Kwara State, Saheed Olayinka, said the worst is not yet over, arguing that the government has yet to tackle the real challenge facing the country.
“The government has not yet solved the economic problem facing the people. It is still chasing the shadows. The people cannot afford three square meals, the insecurity is not yet solved, and the gap between the naira and dollar is widening.’’
Similarly, the TUC Chairman in Bauchi State, Sabiu Barau, admonished the President to face the reality on the ground, noting that the cost of living is still very high.
‘’The masses are still suffering. Farmers in most places cannot go to the farm for fear of being attacked or kidnapped. There is no power supply. There are a lot of issues as far as I am concerned.”
He maintained that workers in the country are struggling to survive, noting that “The N70,000 new minimum wage is not enough.
“Most importantly, the aspect of the consequential adjustment is provocative. It may interest you to know that some workers got less than a N10,000 increase.”
Sunny James, the Akwa Ibom NLC Chairman, challenged Tinubu to show the practical evidence of what he has been able to do for Nigerians in the last two years.
“It’s not the issue of rhetoric; what is important and what Nigerians and workers are expecting is practical evidence. We want people who can walk the talk.
‘’If he says the worst days are over, is it in the area of employment? Is it in the area of security when our roads are still not safe and people cannot sleep with their eyes closed? Nigerians can no longer tolerate promises; what we want is practical evidence,” he demanded.
The Benue State TUC Chairman, Gideon Akaa, described as laughable Tinubu’s submission that ‘’Nigeria’s worst days are over.’’
“Have the exchange rates dropped? Has inflation gone down? Have the prices of consumables in the market dropped? What about the electricity tariff? I think these are the indices to measure our standard.
“You say you increased salary, but can N70,000 feed a family of four in a month? You cannot travel without your heart in your mouth because of kidnappers. Insecurity is on the rise every day, and you are saying the worst is over. Well, I’m yet to see that,” Akaa said.
Also, the labour leaders in Jigawa and Kaduna disagreed with the President’s optimism, stressing that the situation does not support his claim.
Sunusi Maigatari, the NLC Chairman in Jigawa State, noted, “We cannot agree with the President’s claim when the reality on the ground is that Nigerians are still grappling with hunger and hardship. The removal of fuel subsidy and the floating of the naira have led to unprecedented inflation, making it difficult for ordinary Nigerians to make ends meet. The President’s claim that the worst days are over is far from the truth.”
He expressed concern about the suffering of citizens, particularly workers and the poor.
The Kaduna State Chairman of the NLC, Suleiman Ayuba, expressed scepticism over the Nigerian leader’s promise, adding that his administration has not done enough to address poverty in the country.
“We want to see action and not statements,” Ayuba said. ‘’He has been saying that even during the electioneering. They said they would bring all the goodies, and up till now we are still waiting.”
Ayuba questioned the President’s sincerity, asking if he meant to say that Nigeria’s worst days are over in the past two years or the next two years.
Furthermore, the Bayelsa State Chairman of the Trade Union Congress, Laye Julius, and the Imo State NLC Chairman, Chigaemezu Nwigwe, dismissed Tinubu’s promises as a political statement.
Julius argued that with the level of insecurity, poor electricity supply, lack of employment for youths, exchange rate and continued borrowing, the country was worse off.
“You are seeing that the security challenge in the North has not abated. In the past few months, we have lost several soldiers.
“And when you come to Benue State, Nigerians are being killed daily, and the President is saying the worst days are over?’’
Nwigwe said there was nothing to reflect the claim, even as he said the minimum wage implementation by the Federal Government was poor.
Murtala Usman, the NLC boss in Kebbi State, advised the President to review the minimum wage.
His TUC counterpart, Alhaji Atiku Alkali, equally asked the President to improve the workers’ welfare.
Reacting to Tinubu’s statement, the NLC leader in Plateau State, Eugene Mangji, said, “I don’t know the indices he used to measure the situation in the country which led him to arrive at that conclusion.”
Mangji noted that the NLC has yet to experience the positive impact of the government’s policies.
The NLC chairman highlighted the stark contrast between the struggles of ordinary Nigerians and the seeming prosperity of some individuals, saying, “As we are crying, some people are building houses. The government is confiscating over 700 buildings at a time people are crying that they don’t have money.”
APC kicks
Countering NLC, the APC National Vice Chairman, Arodiogbu, insisted that Tinubu has performed creditably
“President Tinubu has a solid track record. I’ve reviewed his achievements personally, and I believe he deserves credit. People rarely praise an administration while it’s still in office; it’s usually after it’s gone that the true impact is recognised.”
He further noted that Tinubu was not pursuing populist policies, but rather making tough, necessary decisions for the country’s future.
“He has been transparent with Nigerians about the challenges we face and the sacrifices required for a better tomorrow. That’s what sets him apart from the opposition.”